• Overall
• Prices
• Performance
• Exterior
• Interior
• Safety
• Reliability
• Photos & Videos

Aston Martin Vantage - What the Auto Press Says

The 2009 Aston Martin Vantage ranks 4 out of 8 Exotic Sports Cars. This ranking is based on our analysis of 41 published reviews and test drives of the Aston Martin Vantage, and our analysis of reliability and safety data.

Though Aston Martin has used the name "Vantage" since the 1970s, the 2009 V8 Vantage is an entirely different machine. Still in its first generation of production, it was introduced in 2005 to compete with such vehicles as the Porsche 911 Carrera and BMW M6.

While it certainly isn't the quickest vehicle in its class, reviewers find that the Vantage has a lot to offer -- an attractive combination of exclusivity, elegance, and sports performance that few competitors at this price point can match. According to Edmunds, "Though other sports cars costing considerably less money can match or better the Vantage's straight-line performance, none, with the exception of the Porsche 911 and Audi R8, can provide such an enjoyable and exotic driving experience overall." Adding to the allure of the V8 Vantage is Aston Martin's exotic aura -- especially in the United States, where the automaker's vehicles are still rare.

Before buying a Vantage, test drive an Audi R8. It's not as exotic or elegant as the Vantage, but it's certainly as eye-catching. Some might even argue that it looks more menacing. The 911 Carrera also makes a great choice -- especially in terms of performance. However, those seeking exclusivity will be turned off by its not-so-exotic presence.

Though the '09 Vantage is largely a carryover from the previous model year, notable performance-enhancing upgrades have been made. Popular Mechanics says "loads of mechanical upgrades enhance virtually every aspect of the car's performance. The engine has grown from 4.3 to 4.8 liters, and output has leapt by 40 ponies to 420 hp, just as torque has climbed by 44 lb.-ft. to 346."

The 2009 V8 Vantage is available as a coupe and convertible.

• "Besides its exclusivity, the Aston Martin V8 Vantage roadster offers precise handling dynamics that make you feel like a hero when you're carving through mountain roads, luxury accommodations that allow you to drive in a relaxed and confident manner through busy traffic, and a sensuous shape that begs you to caress its tapering flanks." -- Automobile Magazine
• "At $110,000, it is -- in this class -- a bargain. Add the allure of the Aston name and we wouldn't be surprised if the British maker achieves its admittedly aggressive sales goals." -- BusinessWeek
• "[A]t an estimated price of $120,000 for the coupe, it carries a balance of gorgeous design, hand-built charisma, and outright performance that is tough to beat. Finally after three years, the baby Aston is a true competitor for both the Porsche 911 Turbo and Audi R8." -- Car and Driver

Vantage Performance - 8.9 (Very Good)

Test drivers report that the Vantage handles well on and off the track. "New Bilstein dampers, revised suspension geometry, and an available stiffer sport suspension are all new for 2009," reports Automobile Magazine. "Where the old car always felt outshined in outright handling by a Porsche 911 and in ride quality by the Jaguar XKR, the new car is an improvement in both areas." Read More

Vantage Exterior - 9.4 (Excellent)

Reviewers are captivated by the Vantage's beautiful lines. Available as both a coupe and convertible, it not only turns heads, but locks eyes. Critics are especially enamored by its drop-top. "The 20 seconds it takes to automatically stow the softtop under its sleek twin-fairing cover are 20 good reasons to play the lottery," writes Car and Driver. Read More

Vantage Interior - 7.8 (Good)

The Vantage may have an elegant interior, but critics say it's not comfortable for everyone. Edmunds bluntly explains, "The V8 Vantage's seats aren't for the wide-of-butt." What's more, it lacks some features that drivers have come to expect as standard equipment. Read More

Vantage Safety - NA

Neither the federal government nor insurance industry has crash tested the 2009 Vantage. Still, it comes equipped with a wide variety of safety equipment. Visibility issues, however, are a point of concern. Read More

Vantage Reliability - NA

Aston Martin covers the '09 Vantage with a three-year/unlimited-mile warranty. Read More