#4

in Luxury Sports Cars

Based on analysis of 37 Exige reviews and test drives.

MSRP: $65,690 - $74,995
Invoice: NA
MPG: 20 City / 26 Hwy
Get local dealer price quotes:

U.S.News Scores

Overall:8.8
Performance:9.3
Exterior:9.2
Interior:5.3
Safety:NA
Reliability:NA
Pros and Cons
  • Excellent power and handling
  • Functional, eye-catching exterior
  • Few safety and convenience features
  • Hard to access, low slung cabin
  • Stiff suspension impedes daily use

Prices

Shop around for the best deal by getting price quotes from local dealers.

Lotus Exige - What the Auto Press Says

The 2009 Lotus Exige ranks 4 out of 9 Luxury Sports Cars. This ranking is based on our analysis of 37 published reviews and test drives of the Lotus Exige, and our analysis of reliability and safety data.

The Lotus Exige is a track junkie's dream come true -- offering mind-blowing speeds and unrivaled handling dynamics. However, it rides stiff and lacks luxury, making it less fit for daily use than some of its rivals.

The 2009 Exige is engineered for one thing only -- performance. In fact, almost every other aspect of it was designed with its performance capabilities in mind. If you can appreciate that, then you won't mind its sparse cabin, which forgoes luxury and convenience to save weight. Disappointing? Maybe. But in the end, it proves well worth it. In fact, Autobytel writes: "Flamboyant and fun, elemental and efficient, there are few cars on the market built strictly to address the joy of driving. The Lotus Exige S is one of those rare, purpose-built automobiles that make getting behind the wheel a thrill rather than a chore. We need more cars like this."

If you're in the market for a track-tuned beast of a machine, but can't stomach the Exige's hefty price tag, consider a Honda S2000 Club Racer. It's not as eye-catching as the Exige, but offers mind-blowing performance for an affordable price. Plus, it features a removable aluminum hardtop -- which offers relief on hot days at the track.

The '09 Exige is available in two trims, S and S 240. Both feature a 1.8-liter supercharged four-cylinder engine.

  • "This is a track-ready missile that shares its chassis and interior with the Elise. The Exige S, however, doesn't have a removable top, and it has different body panels and a rear wing, the latter to increase downforce. For those interested in an all-out track toy, the Exige is an excellent choice." -- Car and Driver
  • "Obviously, there are also moments of stunned amazement, because this is a truly uncompromised sports car, and extended periods of low-level irritation, occasionally verging on terror, because this is one godawful car in traffic and around town. But this compact little collection of wings, vents, spoilers, handling, oomph, and grip was built to order from the happiest days of your childhood." -- Jalopnik
  • "The Exige, however, exists for those live-fast die-hard enthusiasts who don't give a crap about cupholders, sat-nav, luggage capacity, impact harshness, HVAC, NVH, ESP, XYZ, or any other nifty electro-mechanic nuisance with an obscure acronym." -- Edmunds
  • "Certainly the Exige S isn't for everyone, but for the true enthusiast who reveres performance-oriented driving dynamics ... this is as undefiled a road car that money can buy." -- Automobile.com
  • "Some car guys know the price of everything and the value of nothing, as car guy Oscar Wilde put it. Others value efficiency and purity at any price; size doesn't matter. The Exige--the best-handling, purest, most entertaining production sports car on the road--is for them." -- Forbes

Exige Performance - 9.3 (Excellent)

Test drivers are in awe of the Exige's thrilling performance and handling dynamics. "Undiluted driving at its best, with fantastic steering and brake feel, and unstoppable on a racetrack," writes Car and Driver. "The peaky engine takes some abuse to keep on boil. Only masochists would use this as a daily driver." Best of all, its 0 to 60 mph time will blow you away. Read More

Exige Exterior - 9.2 (Excellent)

Critics agree the Exige is an eye-catcher. Cars.com describes it as "flamboyantly styled," writing that its "appearance is augmented by a variety of vents and curves -- some shapely, others practical in nature." Read More

Exige Interior - 5.3 (Mediocre)

Reviewers complain that the Lotus Exige's cabin doesn't provide much luxury and is hard to access. "In the 1950s, cars were sold with the implicitly understood abbreviation R&H, meaning radio and heater, as part of the pitch," writes Forbes. "It meant the car was flush with options, and these two creature comforts, plus air-conditioning and power windows, are about it for the Exige." Still, reviewers claim that luxury isn't what the Exige is meant for. Read More

Exige Safety - NA

The 2009 Lotus Exige hasn't been crash-tested by the federal government or insurance industry. Even more disappointing, it comes with minimal safety features. Read More

Exige Reliability - NA

Lotus provides a three-year/36,000-mile basic warranty. Read More

Review Last Updated: 6/16/09