GO
#13

in 2009 Affordable Small Cars

Avg. Price Paid: $10,454 - $18,389
Original MSRP: $18,550 - $34,300
MPG: 28 City / 37 Hwy

Used Car: 2009 MINI Cooper Review

Review Last Updated: 7/31/12

The 2009 Mini Cooper is fun to drive and fuel-efficient, but a cramped cabin makes it less practical than other small cars.

The 2009 MINI Cooper is ranked:

Available as a hardtop or a convertible, the 2009 Mini Cooper has nimble road manners and outstanding fuel economy ratings. Of the three available trims, reviewers said the base model was fun, but the Cooper S and John Cooper Works models have more satisfying power. At 28/37 mpg city/highway, the base model gets the best fuel economy ratings. As a new model, the 2009 Mini Cooper was expensive for a small car.

The 2009 Mini Cooper’s interior has a lot of standard features such as air conditioning, power accessories and a six-speaker stereo with an auxiliary port. Options when it was new included a USB port, Bluetooth and navigation. Though the base model is loaded with features, the four-seat Cooper has one of the tightest back seats in the class and little cargo space. Additionally, reviewers felt the design and controls were distracting and confusing.

The Cooper does well in safety tests, but its comparatively high price may make practical-minded shoppers look elsewhere. In terms of reliability, the 2009 Mini Cooper earns a score that’s about average for the class.

See the full 2009 Mini Cooper specs »

See More Photos »

Other Cars to Consider

Reviewers found that the 2009 Volkswagen Rabbit meshes practicality and spirited driving. The Rabbit’s rear seat is surprisingly spacious, and there’s also a lot more cargo space than what the Cooper has to offer. Like the Cooper, the Rabbit has a quality interior and is equipped with more standard interior and safety features than many of its classmates. The Rabbit has worse fuel economy ratings than the Cooper, but both cars earn similar reliability scores.

The 2009 Honda Fit has comfortable seating for five and enough cargo space to compete with some compact SUVs. The Fit only comes with one engine, but reviewers still said it’s fun to drive. The Fit doesn’t have as many standard safety features as the Cooper, but its safety ratings are good and its reliability score is above-average.

Compare the Cooper to the Rabbit and Fit »