• Overall
• Prices
• Performance
• Exterior
• Interior
• Safety
• Reliability
• Photos & Videos

Toyota Sienna - What the Auto Press Says

The 2010 Toyota Sienna ranks 2 out of 7 Minivans. This ranking is based on our analysis of 28 published reviews and test drives of the Toyota Sienna, and our analysis of reliability and safety data.

The Toyota Sienna is a comfortable, peppy minivan with plenty of space for the family. The base Sienna represents a great value, while its top-of-the-line Limited trim brings a luxury feel to the minivan segment.

The Sienna is not one of the vehicles affected by the recent Toyota recall.

The Sienna delivers one of the best combinations of acceleration, interior space and general quality in its class. Value hunters should take note of the base trim. Edmunds says, "Budget-minded shoppers will like the low-priced Sienna CE that has room for up to eight passengers. Those who can spend considerably more will appreciate how the Sienna Limited comes off like nothing less than a Lexus minivan."

The Sienna and its main rival, the Honda Odyssey, are generally considered to be the benchmarks of their class. However, the Sienna starts at about $2,000 less than the Odyssey.  If you want an even better deal, consider the Kia Sedona.  Reviewers like it just as much as they like the Sienna, but the Sedona costs about $2,000 less and has longer warranty coverage.

Buyers who are wary of the Sienna because of the recent recall of eight Toyota models should know that the Sienna was not one of the recalled models.  However, it is unclear what the fallout from Toyota's sticking accelerator issue will mean for the long-term value of Toyota models.

The Toyota Sienna gets high marks from reviewers for its high-quality interior and performance that's easy to live with. Car and Driver says "the Sienna has Camry-like driving manners," and most reviewers agree.  While there are a few complaints about the Sienna's size (it's one of the largest minivans available) there's no quibbling with its flexibility and long list of available features.   

One of those standout features is available all-wheel drive.  The Sienna is the only minivan to offer it. Though all-wheel drive's extra weight negatively impacts fuel economy, it makes the Sienna a viable SUV alternative for people who routinely have to face bad weather. Plus, an all-wheel drive Sienna's 16/21 city/highway EPA-estimated fuel economy is still better than what most eight passenger SUVs get, even if it's not as good as the two-wheel drive Sienna's 17/23 city/highway mileage.  

The Sienna is available in four trim levels: the base CE and the higher-level LE, XLE, and Limited. All but the CE are available with all-wheel drive. There are no changes for the 2010 model year.

Be sure to check for current Toyota deals that may be available on a new Sienna.

• "Roomy, comfortable and well-built, the 2010 Toyota Sienna minivan is an excellent choice for larger families." -- Edmunds
• "There are those who say that minivans are too large, and that a family needs no more than a compact sedan. Our family, however, thinks no vehicle is too large, and they can fill up anything you choose to throw at them. While my wife and I both remember family vacations with nothing more than a sedan, traveling is much better in a great family 'car' like the Toyota Sienna minivan." -- The Auto Channel
• "The ... Toyota Sienna had me assessing the value of my soul. You see, I'm ready to sell it to Toyota for a Sienna minivan." -- Mother Proof
• "This Recommended minivan combines good ideas from rivals with its own appealing pluses, including first-rate refinement, build quality, and car-like road manners. Sienna prices are steep for lavishly equipped models, but that's offset somewhat by Toyota's reputation for strong resale value." -- Consumer Guide
• "If one needs a lot of passenger and cargo room -- and no one would buy a minivan if they didn't -- then the Sienna gets our vote as one terrific family car." -- Forbes

Sienna Performance - 8.1 (Very Good)

The 2010 Toyota Sienna receives high marks for its pleasant ride and surprisingly good acceleration.  Edmunds says, "All Sienna trim levels come with Toyota's familiar 3.5-liter V6, an all-star engine renowned for its smooth power and high fuel efficiency. Another feather in the Sienna's cap is the fact that it's currently the only minivan to be offered with all-wheel drive, so if you live where ice and snow are common, the Sienna has a decided advantage over its rivals." Still, some reviewers note the Sienna's disappointing handling.  Read More

Sienna Exterior - 7.7 (Good)

The Sienna is by no means a stunner, but it does have appealing lines for a minivan. U.S. News reviewer Rick Newman notes, "The Sienna has some trendy styling and some sharp edges that help it stand out (from a rather sedate crowd)." Read More

Sienna Interior - 8.7 (Very Good)

The Sienna's cabin receives positive reviews for its build quality, functional layout and spaciousness. Edmunds says, "The Sienna's cabin is handsomely fitted with high-quality fabric on lower trim levels and leather and faux wood on the higher-end models. The various controls are simple to use, storage space is plentiful and the seats are plush." Read More

Sienna Safety - 7.8 (Good)

The 2010 Sienna performs well in crash tests conducted by the federal government. Forbes says, "One of the main considerations for any family car should be safety, and here too the Sienna scores well."     Read More

Sienna Reliability - 6.0 (Mediocre)

The 2010 Toyota Sienna reliability score shown is the Predicted Reliability rating provided by J.D. Power and Associates. This score is based on trending the past three years of historical initial quality and dependability data from J.D. Power's automotive studies, specifically the Vehicle Dependability Study (VDS) and the Initial Quality Study (IQS). Toyota offers competitive warranty coverage on all of its cars, including a three-year/36,000-mile basic warranty.  Read More