Car Rankings: Exotic Sports Cars

We are still compiling our scores for our ranking of exotic sports cars. Please check back soon.

Lamborghini Murcielago Image
  • MSRP: $354,000 - $382,400
  • Invoice: NA
  • MPG: 8 City / 13 Hwy

#1
2009 Lamborghini Murcielago

The Lamborghini Murcielago flies like a bat out of hell. While other supercars may offer more comfortable accommodations, few can match its lustful design and superior performance ...

U.S.News Scores
Overall:9.3
Performance:9.2
Exterior:9.5
Interior:8.0
Safety:NA
Reliability:NA
Ferrari 612 Scaglietti Image
  • MSRP: $299,720 - $299,720
  • Invoice: NA
  • MPG: 10 City / 15 Hwy

#2
2009 Ferrari 612 Scaglietti

The 612 Scaglietti is a one-of-a-kind high-performance four-seater that cuts no corners when it comes to luxury.

U.S.News Scores
Overall:9.2
Performance:9.5
Exterior:7.7
Interior:8.4
Safety:NA
Reliability:NA
Lamborghini Gallardo Image
  • MSRP: $198,000 - $198,000
  • Invoice: NA
  • MPG: 12 City / 20 Hwy

#3
2009 Lamborghini Gallardo

The Lamborghini Gallardo is lust on wheels -- combining sexy, look-at-me styling with mind-numbing performance capabilities.

U.S.News Scores
Overall:9.1
Performance:8.9
Exterior:9.3
Interior:8.3
Safety:NA
Reliability:NA
Aston Martin DB9 Image
  • MSRP: $182,450 - $199,950
  • Invoice: NA
  • MPG: 11 City / 17 Hwy

#4
2009 Aston Martin DB9

Most auto writers agree that the '09 DB9 conveys power and exclusivity. Its elegant and understated design oozes success.

U.S.News Scores
Overall:9.0
Performance:9.0
Exterior:9.5
Interior:8.0
Safety:NA
Reliability:NA
Aston Martin Vantage Image
  • MSRP: $119,500 - $136,500
  • Invoice: NA
  • MPG: 12 City / 19 Hwy

#4
2009 Aston Martin Vantage

Though Aston Martin has used the name "Vantage" since the 1970s, the 2009 V8 Vantage is an entirely different machine. Still in its first generation of production, ...

U.S.News Scores
Overall:9.0
Performance:8.9
Exterior:9.4
Interior:7.8
Safety:NA
Reliability:NA
Ferrari California Image
  • MSRP: NA
  • Invoice: NA
  • MPG: NA

#6
2009 Ferrari California

Praised for its combination of sports performance, elegance and everyday practicality, the 2009 California is the perfect car for those in need of more panache than a ...

U.S.News Scores
Overall:8.8
Performance:9.2
Exterior:8.0
Interior:8.0
Safety:NA
Reliability:NA
Audi R8 Image
  • MSRP: $114,200 - $155,100
  • Invoice: $106,206 - $144,243
  • Avg. Paid: $118,691 - $164,326
  • MPG: 12 City / 19 Hwy

#7
2010 Audi R8

The Audi R8 is admired for its sporty yet comfortable nature. Combined with head-turning style and a luxurious cabin, it gives higher-priced exotics a run for their ...

U.S.News Scores
Overall:8.6
Performance:9.0
Exterior:9.1
Interior:8.6
Safety:NA
Reliability:6.0
Mercedes-Benz SLR McLaren Image
  • MSRP: $495,000 - $495,000
  • Invoice: $460,350 - $460,350
  • Avg. Paid: $484,517 - $484,517
  • MPG: 12 City / 16 Hwy

#8
2009 Mercedes-Benz SLR McLaren

The 2009 SLR McLaren is as much about exclusivity as it is speed. Starting at nearly half a million dollars, how couldn't it be?

U.S.News Scores
Overall:8.3
Performance:9.3
Exterior:9.0
Interior:8.0
Safety:NA
Reliability:6.0

Unranked: Exotic Sports Cars

Our rankings are based on analysis of third party reviews. Sometimes, we are unable to find enough reviews to publish a definitive ranking. Please check back later, as we are constantly updating our reviews.

Acura NSX Image

2009 Acura NSX

MSRP: NA | Invoice: NA | MPG: NA

Ferrari 599 GTB Fiorano Image

2009 Ferrari 599 GTB Fiorano

MSRP: $302,584 - $302,584 | Invoice: NA | MPG: 11 City / 15 Hwy

Ferrari F430 Image

2009 Ferrari F430

MSRP: $186,925 - $281,618 | Invoice: NA | MPG: 11 (Est) City / 16 (Est) Hwy

Ferrari F458 Italia Image

2010 Ferrari F458 Italia

MSRP: NA | Invoice: NA | MPG: NA