GO

Used Cars: 2009 Affordable Midsize Cars

View the best 2009 Affordable Midsize Cars based on our rankings. Then read our used car reviews, compare specs and features, and find 2009 Affordable Midsize Cars for sale in your area. Learn more about our rankings»

(Choose up to 3 cars)
Compare Cars
Compare
Honda Accord Image

#1
2009 Honda Accord

The 2009 Honda Accord is a highly-ranked 2009 midsize car that reviewers praised for its sporty performance and power, as well as its high-quality interior. The Accord ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 9.3
Critics' Rating: 9.4
Performance: 8.2
Interior: 8.6
Cost to Own: 9.3
Safety: 9.8
Reliability: 5_0
Compare
Saturn Aura Image

#2
2009 Saturn Aura

If you’re looking for a used midsize car that prioritizes performance over a high-quality cabin, the 2009 Saturn Aura should be on your short list. When it ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 9.0
Critics' Rating: 8.8
Performance: 8.2
Interior: 7.8
Cost to Own: N/A
Safety: 9.2
Reliability: 5_0
Compare
Toyota Camry Hybrid Image

#3
2009 Toyota Camry Hybrid

Good fuel economy is one of the 2009 Toyota Camry Hybrid’s best attributes, as it has some of the highest ratings in its class. Its high reliability ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 8.8
Critics' Rating: 9.1
Performance: 7.9
Interior: 8.2
Cost to Own: 9.5
Safety: 9.4
Reliability: 4_0
Compare
Ford Fusion Image

#4
2009 Ford Fusion

The 2009 Ford Fusion’s sporty handling, spacious interior and outstanding safety and reliability scores make it a great used car. Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 8.7
Critics' Rating: 8.9
Performance: 7.9
Interior: 8.2
Cost to Own: 9.3
Safety: 9.6
Reliability: 4_0
Compare
Toyota Camry Image

#4
2009 Toyota Camry

With a spacious interior and satisfying performance, it’s no surprise that we named the 2009 Toyota Camry ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 8.7
Critics' Rating: 9.1
Performance: 7.6
Interior: 8.4
Cost to Own: 9.5
Safety: 9.2
Reliability: 4_0
Compare
Mazda Mazda6 Image

#6
2009 Mazda Mazda6

When it was new, reviewers agreed that the Mazda6 was one of the sportiest 2009 midsize cars thanks to its outstanding performance. The Mazda6’s bold styling, roomy ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 8.5
Critics' Rating: 9.1
Performance: 8.9
Interior: 8.2
Cost to Own: 9.4
Safety: 9.8
Reliability: 3_0
Compare
Mercury Milan Image

#6
2009 Mercury Milan

Thanks to its engaging handling and available all-wheel drive, the 2009 Mercury Milan is an appealing used car. The Milan is also a good midsize car for ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 8.5
Critics' Rating: 8.4
Performance: 7.4
Interior: 7.6
Cost to Own: 9.3
Safety: 9.6
Reliability: 4_0
Compare
Nissan Altima Image

#8
2009 Nissan Altima

The 2009 Nissan Altima is a good choice for used car shoppers who prioritize strong driving dynamics and good fuel economy. However, the Altima’s low reliability score ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 8.3
Critics' Rating: 8.7
Performance: 8.4
Interior: 7.7
Cost to Own: 9.4
Safety: 9.3
Reliability: 3_0
Compare
Nissan Altima Hybrid Image

#8
2009 Nissan Altima Hybrid

The 2009 Nissan Altima Hybrid has some of the best fuel economy ratings in its class, and its high safety scores should appeal to family-minded shoppers. However, ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 8.3
Critics' Rating: 8.3
Performance: 7.9
Interior: 8.6
Cost to Own: 9.6
Safety: 9.4
Reliability: 3_0
Compare
Kia Optima Image

#10
2009 Kia Optima

Used car shoppers who want a midsize sedan with respectable performance will like the 2009 Kia Optima, but test drivers agreed that it lacks the personality and ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 8.2
Critics' Rating: 8.5
Performance: 8.2
Interior: 7.8
Cost to Own: 9.5
Safety: 9.1
Reliability: 3_0
Compare
Toyota Prius Image

#11
2009 Toyota Prius

If you’re shopping for a used car that gets exceptional fuel economy, the 2009 Toyota Prius should be on your list. With an outstanding reliability rating and ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 8.1
Critics' Rating: 9.1
Performance: 7.4
Interior: 7.3
Cost to Own: 9.5
Safety: 8.7
Reliability: 3_0
Compare
Chevrolet Malibu Image

#12
2009 Chevrolet Malibu

The 2009 Chevrolet Malibu is a great family sedan, thanks to its spacious interior and trunk, as well as competitive fuel economy ratings. However, its reliability and ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 8.0
Critics' Rating: 9.4
Performance: 7.9
Interior: 8.4
Cost to Own: 9.4
Safety: 9.2
Reliability: 2_0
Compare
Subaru Legacy Image

#13
2009 Subaru Legacy

Used car shoppers who are looking for a safe midsize sedan with standard all-wheel drive will like the 2009 Subaru Legacy, but its fuel economy and reliability ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 7.9
Critics' Rating: 8.8
Performance: 8.7
Interior: 7.9
Cost to Own: 9.1
Safety: 9.4
Reliability: 2_0
Compare
Hyundai Sonata Image

#14
2009 Hyundai Sonata

The 2009 Hyundai Sonata is a good used midsize car for many types of buyers, and auto critics agreed that families who are looking for space and ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 7.8
Critics' Rating: 8.8
Performance: 7.6
Interior: 8.4
Cost to Own: 9.5
Safety: 9.1
Reliability: 2_0
Compare
Saturn Aura Hybrid Image

#15
2009 Saturn Aura Hybrid

The 2009 Saturn Aura Hybrid can’t match the fuel economy of other midsize hybrid cars. Tie-in the Aura Hybrid’s sluggish performance and auto critics agreed that other ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 7.6
Critics' Rating: 8.0
Performance: 6.5
Interior: 7.8
Cost to Own: N/A
Safety: 9.4
Reliability: 3_0
Compare
Volkswagen Passat Image

#15
2009 Volkswagen Passat

The 2009 Volkswagen Passat has the interior space, features and safety ratings many families are looking for in their next used sedan. But with one of the ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 7.6
Critics' Rating: 8.2
Performance: 8.0
Interior: 8.3
Cost to Own: 9.1
Safety: 8.9
Reliability: 2_0
Compare
Dodge Avenger Image

#17
2009 Dodge Avenger

Aside from decent safety scores and a roomy interior, the 2009 Dodge Avenger is a run-of-the-mill used car that trails its competition with uninspiring driving dynamics and ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 7.5
Critics' Rating: 6.3
Performance: 6.5
Interior: 7.0
Cost to Own: 9.5
Safety: 9.2
Reliability: 3_0
Compare
Mitsubishi Galant Image

#17
2009 Mitsubishi Galant

Reviewers agreed that with a run-of-the-mill powertrain and interior, the 2009 Mitsubishi Galant is an acceptable used car, but there are many others that are better.   Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 7.5
Critics' Rating: 7.4
Performance: 8.3
Interior: 7.7
Cost to Own: 9.3
Safety: 8.9
Reliability: 2_0
Compare
Pontiac G6 Image

#19
2009 Pontiac G6

The base 2009 Pontiac G6 is stylish and has good fuel economy, but its subpar reliability rating may cause some used car shoppers to think twice. Although ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 6.9
Critics' Rating: 6.6
Performance: 6.8
Interior: 7.1
Cost to Own: N/A
Safety: 9.3
Reliability: 2_5
Compare
Chrysler Sebring Image

#20
2009 Chrysler Sebring

If you’re in the market for a used midsize car, there are a lot of choices that are better than the 2009 Chrysler Sebring, as reviewers were ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall: 6.8
Critics' Rating: 7.0
Performance: 6.7
Interior: 7.8
Cost to Own: N/A
Safety: 9.2
Reliability: 2_0
(Choose up to 3 cars)
Compare Cars
Total Cost of Ownership data is provided by Vincentric, LLC
Used car average prices are provided by ClearBook™, a TrueCar™ product

Safety scores should only be compared between vehicles of similar size and weight. Larger, heavier vehicles generally provide more protection than smaller, lighter ones.