GO

Used Cars: 2009 Affordable Sports Cars

View the best 2009 Affordable Sports Cars based on our rankings. Then read our used car reviews, compare specs and features, and find 2009 Affordable Sports Cars for sale in your area. Learn more about our rankings»

(Choose up to 3 cars)
Compare Cars
Compare
Mazda MX-5 Miata Image

#1
2009 Mazda MX-5 Miata

The 2009 Mazda Miata is at the top of its class with a high reliability score, responsive ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall:8.7
Critics' Rating:9.4
Performance:8.8
Interior:6.8
Operating Cost:7.8
Safety:N/A
Reliability:
Compare
Ford Mustang Image

#2
2009 Ford Mustang

The 2009 Ford Mustang ranks high due to its stellar safety score, high reliability and useful second-row seating. Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall:8.4
Critics' Rating:8.8
Performance:8.3
Interior:7.4
Operating Cost:7.6
Safety:9.7
Reliability:
Compare
Honda S2000 Image

#2
2009 Honda S2000

The 2009 Honda S2000 ranks high in reliability and performance, but there are other affordable sports cars with more comfortable seating. Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall:8.4
Critics' Rating:8.9
Performance:9.2
Interior:6.9
Operating Cost:7.3
Safety:9.1
Reliability:
Compare
Nissan 370Z Image

#2
2009 Nissan 370Z

With exceptional handling and a powerful V6, reviewers agreed that the 2009 Nissan 370Z is one of the most fun-to-drive cars in the class.  Read full review »

Used Car Scores
Overall:8.4
Critics' Rating:8.7
Performance:8.8
Interior:7.4
Operating Cost:7.4
Safety:N/A
Reliability:
Compare
Dodge Challenger Image

#5
2009 Dodge Challenger

The 2009 Dodge Challenger has strong engines, a spacious cabin and retro styling, though some rivals have better reliability scores or nicer interiors.   Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall:8.1
Critics' Rating:9.0
Performance:8.6
Interior:7.7
Operating Cost:7.3
Safety:9.4
Reliability:
Compare
Mazda RX-8 Image

#6
2009 Mazda RX-8

A poor reliability score and a weak engine drag the 2009 Mazda RX-8 to the lower end of the class. Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall:8.0
Critics' Rating:8.8
Performance:8.4
Interior:7.8
Operating Cost:7.2
Safety:9.1
Reliability:
Compare
Pontiac Solstice Image

#7
2009 Pontiac Solstice

With an underperforming base engine and low safety score, the 2009 Pontiac Solstice doesn't rank well in its class. Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall:7.7
Critics' Rating:8.1
Performance:7.7
Interior:6.4
Operating Cost:7.6
Safety:8.6
Reliability:
Compare
Mitsubishi Eclipse Image

#8
2009 Mitsubishi Eclipse

Available as a coupe or convertible, the 2009 Mitsubishi Eclipse has some of the best fuel economy ratings in the class. However, the Eclipse falters with poor ... Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall:7.6
Critics' Rating:7.6
Performance:7.6
Interior:7.4
Operating Cost:7.5
Safety:9.7
Reliability:
Compare
Saturn Sky Image

#9
2009 Saturn Sky

The 2009 Saturn Sky disappointed test drivers with its inadequate base engine and low safety and reliability scores. Read full review »

Used Listings For Sale:
Used Car Scores
Overall:7.5
Critics' Rating:7.8
Performance:7.9
Interior:6.8
Operating Cost:7.5
Safety:8.6
Reliability:
(Choose up to 3 cars)
Compare Cars
Operating cost data is provided by Vincentric, LLC Used car average prices are provided by ClearBook™, a TrueCar™ product

Safety scores should only be compared between vehicles of similar size and weight. Larger, heavier vehicles generally provide more protection than smaller, lighter ones.